On Veteran's Day, 2015. M*A*S*H's final
episode aired. I only remember it once being shown since the
original aired in 1983. It is said to be the best of any finale of
any show and was watched by a record number in it's day. It is great,
and heavy, so cerebral and leagues above finales of shows like
Seinfeld and even Cheers. For me, the finale of M*A*S*H
pushed the concept of “dramedy” too far. It was so orchestrated,
so well done and telling of each character's psyche comedy was hard
to approach. It was too big, too thinking for a twenty-minute show.
The two hour plus finale was like another show. The formula changed
and the war was over, but no one was laughing. They were just happy
to go home, each in their individual way. Klinger got married.
Hawkeye had to find his sanity. BJ had to go home and then come
back. War is hell, so I've heard; some line of monologue I heard
once or twice in the show's ten years.
If I had any criticism of M*A*S*H I
want to say it got too preachy in the later seasons. That line
between comedy and drama got unbalanced, and drama became the heavy.
The loss and senselessness of war, its proclivity to degenerate,
became a hackneyed line for scripts. The show, in the last seasons, I
think too often pointed out the costs and deficiencies of war. Even
the finale told how the life of each character was irrevocably
changed. But that's war. That's hell—or at least purgatory—as
Father Mulcahy says in the finale.
Cheaper by the yardage
M*A*S*H, conceived by the movie, was
said to be about war in general. The series can only be about the
Korean War. It was not interchangeable. That ambiguity the Robert
Altman movie had was gone. The series had overt references to the
Korean War—which lasted three years. By war time, this seems short.
Colonel Potter refers to having fought in WWI, the Great War. Four
years—1914 to 1918—is a little longer. Its death toll—over 9
million plus 7 million civilians—I guess is what earns the title.
WWII—1939 to 1945—was greater in death toll terms, with 73
million combined by allied and axis forces. The Vietnam War
officially lasted just under twenty years—1956 to 1975—but did
not come close to the death tolls of world wars one and two.
War IS hell
In February of 1971 there was an
investigation at a Detroit Howard Johnson. Veterans Against the
Vietnam War convened to expose war crimes. Jane Fonda and John Kerry
were among the tribunal called “the winter soldier investigation.”
The young men who went to Vietnam when their country called, the ones
who at the time thought it was the right thing to do, refused to b
held accountable for their actions. Months on end they “humped”
hills, searching for an enemy they called Charlie. In the case of the
tiny village of May Lai the young men who reported at the conference
were following orders of superiors. They followed blindly, grudgingly
out of frustration. They were numb and mute with desperation. The
winter soldiers reported that no one, neither lieutenants or captains
were given any instruction in how to deal with the enemy. A long
haired mutton-chopped grunt stated they'd been told what to do if the
enemy captured them, but not if the opposite situation arose. They
stated they were never instructed about what the Geneva Convention
affords an enemy.
Serial War
Draftees make war worth fighting for.
In the early days of M*A*S*H Hawkeye and Trapper made life difficult
for Frank Burns. It was draftees versus gunge- ho Burns. In a handful
of episodes during the series Hawkeye states his reluctance to carry
or fire a gun. He is a resolute patriot. Hawkeye's a character of all
those would-be draftees who went to Canada, college, or jail rather
than have a gun stuck in their hands. Hawkeye was in Korea, but I
don't think he was ever in the war. He was on the sidelines binding
the wounded, fighting only to preserve life, and sometimes hating
himself for being on “weapons repair.”
However great the war, whatever the
terms of greatness are, the participants of war are the same. Every
war had its conscientious objectors. Each had he draftees, unwilling
participants who made fighting objectionable. All had its gunge-ho
combatants, the glory seekers who fight regardless of the morality of
the war. On Veterans Day I salute all off these groups. Without any
one of these group war would be an imperfect hell